My cosy coatigan chronicles

Newsletter coatigan blog

Time to wrap up

There’s a tipping point every autumn when I embark on a mission which is all too often futile; my search for the perfect cardigan to take me through the winter. With the recent onset of chilly evenings and nippy mornings the 2018 search fell due this week. As the sun comes round in the morning, the ClothSpot studio is usually toasty warm by coffee time – but those first couple of hours can be punishing. Yet there seems little point in lighting the stove just for an hour or two of heat.

Before you ask, the central heating is waiting for a valve replacement which yes of course, we could and should have sorted out back in May but <insert your excuse of choice>. It was heat or hot water over the summer; we opted for the latter and consequently had hot showers (and were socially acceptable) through the summer months. Only now are we facing the reality of forking out for the boiler engineer to come and put things right and I suspect we’re waaay back in the queue. Consequently there’s a bit of a chill in the air.

Brainwave alert!

Back on the cardigan hunt – of course there are those among you who will urge:

‘Just knit one, Alice!’

Cue roars of laughter from anyone who’s seen me with a pair of knitting needles. There are generations of women in my family who could sew beautifully and a few who could knit too. I was taught to sew dolls’ clothes as far back as I can remember and was happy as a sandgirl doing that. Knitting lessons only resulted in my wooden needles being thrown across the room in frustration. In my defence, I do recall my mother telling me that she was knitting me a cardigan when I was about six. I have good reason to believe that cardigan remains the only thing she has ever completed and moreover, she was still wearing it to do the gardening some decades later. Apparently it ‘went wrong’. In the intervening years I’ve tried and tried again to knit, but have been repeatedly foiled.

Last autumn I was determined to have (yet) another go. Lots of you are accomplished and extraordinarily creative knitters I know. I was encouraged by the wonderful Sarah, who pointed out the portability and mental health benefits of knitting. My yoga chum Sara appointed herself as my knitting mentor and before long I was away, making more progress than I might have dreamed of. A number of phone cases were duly produced and I was proud to note a definite improvement in my technique

Phone case 1

Phone case2Knitted phone cases – quite the thing, don’t you know?

Eventually with Sara’s help I embarked on a cardigan. A year later, and I have almost finished one front panel. (It started off as a sleeve but I got carried away)

I do genuinely enjoy the process of knitting and without doubt it’s helped keep my greedy fingers out of the Kettle Chips of an evening. However at this rate, my efforts probably won’t result in a completed cardigan this side of major climate change.

But (doh) it’s true I do have access to lots of knitted fabrics… Finally the penny dropped and it occurred to me that I might actually sew myself a cardigan.

Cardigan criteria

My cardigan criteria are pretty simple. I’m looking for:

Long sleeves
Honestly, it’s amazing how many cardigans don’t have them. It’s winter. Wrists and arms get cold. What *is* the point of a 3/4 length sleeve on an otherwise warm cardigan?

Warm collar
Not completely essential as I rarely remove my scarf even indoors but I hate that scarf-cardigan gap. It can lead to a chilly neck. We don’t want that.

Longer length
It’s more elegant – plus I do like something to wrap around me. Tunic level is the highest I’ll go – preferably longer for cosy wrapping.

We all know how important they are. The question should always be why *not* to add pockets to a garment, rather than justifying their inclusion. Here’s an excellent article about the politics of pockets, should you need to convince a pattern designer.

But really – leaf through the pattern books and websites; wander round the shops. The count of cardigans that meet all these criteria is surprisingly small.

Pattern choice

The word used to describe a long cardigan is increasingly a ‘coatigan’. It’s a slightly awkward portmanteau term which hasn’t yet made it into my favourite vocabulary bible but it’s increasingly visible on fashion websites and pattern descriptions. I’ve been compiling a page of patterns and fabrics for coatigans on Pinterest for a while now – so do have a trawl through – and let me know if I need to add any.

The pattern I chose to go with is Kwik Sew pattern 4192.

K4192 coatigan pattern for cerise boiled wool fabric

It’s simple and adaptable with clean lines. In a draping fabric that waterfall front might not be to everyone’s taste but it’s also easily re-cut to a different shape.

It does have one critical flaw however; no pocket! However I had a cunning plan to insert one. Away I went.

The making

It really was easy. First was a version in our new ‘Cocoon’ cosy cerise boiled wool fabric’.

Cerise boiled wool fabric coatigan

My cunning plan with the pocket was put into action by inserting a pocket piece and opening into the side seam and stitching it to the front of the coatigan, of which more later.

Finished pocket on Cerise boiled wool coatigan

I used a normal straight stitch for the construction. Other than the pocket, the only amendment I made was to press the seam allowances to one side and stitch them down. Not quite a flat-fell seam but it helped keep the seams flat and the inside neat.

Seam finishing on Cerise boiled wool coatigan

It did mean a fair bit of topstitching and I will readily own up to a bit of unpicking and re-stitching. The wonder of boiled wool though, is that a gentle steam revives the fabric under the unpicked stitching – and really – you’d never know.

I left the edges clean-cut and unfinished (ah, the beauty of boiled wool…) but I hemmed the sleeves for durability. I have to say, I’m incredibly chuffed with the result…

Cerise coatigan portrait

…but I had to conced that what I’d made was more ‘coat’ than ‘coatigan’

As a result I decided to try a version in the charcoal colourway of our ponte Roma jersey fabrics.

Charcoal ponte roma jersey fabric for coatigan‘Bleecker’ charcoal ponte Roma jersey fabric

I hate sewing against the clock – it’s one of many reasons (including my fluency in Anglo Saxon) why you’ll never see me on the Sewing Bee. However I kept half an eye on the time and this version (without pockets for now) took about 90 minutes, despite dealing with phone calls and deliveries.

To construct it I used a stretch stitch on my regular machine for all the seams with the exception of the armholes which I overlocked. I used the same seam approach

Seam finishing of charcoal ponte Roma coatigan

The edges were again left unfinished but I did put a single line of (stretch) stitching all the way around the front, the hem edge and sleeves.

Finished edge of charcoal ponte Roma coatigan

I thought it might be wise just to stabilise the edges, particularly where the fabric was cut at an angle. I will probably add patch pockets in due course, once I get sufficiently irritated with not having them. This was the result.

Grey coatigan portrait

It’s much more draping than the boiled wool version, but still perfectly substantial and able to keep me warm indoors.

The wearing

Well of course – I make two coatigans and we have a near-heatwave. Having said that, I’m thrilled with both. I can imagine that the boiled wool version is going to be incredibly practical. It’s warm and cosy and I adore the colour. It’ll be fabulous to nip in and out of the house when I’m off on errands. My grey ponte Roma version is destined to live on the back of my work chair between desk sessions, and to be thrown on in the evenings when I finally hit the sofa.

Both will be doubtless be augmented by scarves – since they never leave my neck from September through to April, although I frequently have to untangle them from Melton the Cat since they’re his favourite snooze spot.

A bright idea is born – the ClothSpot Coatigan Kit!

I talk to people about ClothSpot (no, really?) and have done so interminably, I’m afraid, for years now. I do try not to but it’s noticeable that party and dinner invitations have dried up. I’m used to monotonal grunts and people’s eyes twitching to the side as they desperately seek an escape route. However at some point before their eyes glaze over the question everyone asks is:

‘Can you do sewing kits for your customers?’

This week (with apologies to President Obama) is our chance to reply

‘Yes, we can!’

Welcome to the ClothSpot Coatigan Kit!

Coatigan kit

The conversations we’ve had with some of you suggested that kits might be well-received, especially for anyone who might be less experienced in selecting fabrics and the process of sewing. My coatigans seemed like the perfect opportunity to test out the idea. The pattern we chose is a really straightforward one – this coatigan is genuinely easy to make and not complicated to fit. It also comes with a Pocket pattern hack in the form of a pattern piece and instructions for adding those pockets.

We know the size range of this particular pattern is a bit limited (XS-S-M-L-XL) but we hope you’ll forgive that as we dip our toe in the water.

We did like the idea that one simple pattern could deliver quite different results depending on the fabric used – and we’re offering our Coatigan Kits in the boiled wool version as well as different colours of our ponte Roma jersey.

Please, do tell…

Do you like the idea? I’d love to know! Even if coatigans aren’t your thing (really??) are sewing kits are something you’d like to see more of? And if so, what might you want to make? Might you like the idea for yourself – or perhaps as a gift to get someone else sewing? If we’re barking up the wrong tree then I trust you won’t hold back…

While you take a look and (hopefully) share your thoughts – I’m off to finish up the checked jacket that has been something of a labour of love over the last six months. Now that I can keep warm while I sew, you never know – I might actually get it finished in time for my next post….

16 thoughts on “My cosy coatigan chronicles

  1. Marion George says:

    Yes please! I mean the coatigan, my only problem is which. The cerise boiled wool I think. I made a similar jacket/coatigan a couple of years ago in cream fleece and it has been one of the most useful things I think I have made. It needs replacing so your kit is very timely. The idea kits is excellent, so go for it. Can I suggest that the pattern choices are kept simple so that they are hackable to the more experienced sewer and for those who want to personalize their make.

    As to knitting, I’m with you. I cannot knit. My only adventure into the world of wool was a jumper for a boyfriend. I was young and in love but the jumper ended up HUGE with sleeves suited to an orangutan and one was longer then the other. Needless to say love didn’t conquer all and I have never knitted anything since.

    • aliceclothspot says:

      Hello Marion – I’m so sorry it’s taken me a while to catch up on the blog replies – you’ll see this Friday that we’ve been a bit busy which will explain it! Thank you *so* much for your feedback – we’ve been listening carefully to people’s comments. Your suggestion to keep pattern choices simple so that those with more experience can play around to their heart’s content is an excellent one which we’ve taken to heart. I love your knitting disaster story! Your jumper obviously did the job – just a shame that you had to put so much work into it 🙂 Did he take the jumper with him, or did you then have to find your true love to fit the jumper in a Cinder-knitter-fella kind of way? It’s the question we’re all asking here!

    • aliceclothspot says:

      Thank you very much! We were amazed how quickly the pink ones flew out but happy to spread a bit of cerise joy! You’re right – once made up, they’re quite different garments – a twofer!

  2. Sarah Skinner says:

    These are wonderful, Alice ! I love the pink on you. Another yes from me for kits. As much as it is great fun choosing material, pattern, notions etc, I still often question my choices and wonder if everything will work together. So, a kit is a perfect solution for a quick win, especially when we can see how wonderfully the material and pattern combine together in your perfect samples. Thank you for the mention ?. I feel with knitting, probably even more than sewing, if you are not feeling the love for a project then you should have no qualms in abandoning it early on. There is no solace to be gained if it is not enjoyable. (Eyes her bag of UFO stuffed behind the sofa no doubt proving a lovely nesting place for some small furry animals …)
    But, I’m so glad you enjoyed your smaller projects and you now have the skill which you can return to when you feel like it.

    • aliceclothspot says:

      Thank you very much indeed for your lovely comments, Sarah – and for the kit-affirmation. I think here at ClothSpot we’d agree that you’ve a real gift for putting fabrics and designs together with elegance. We’d never guess that it might be a source of doubt or concern for you – but your saying that it is, shows that it’s not as easy a process as you make it look. I think that experience has taught a lot of us that there are pitfalls so we just wanted to take a little of the uncertainty away. I’m relieved that they went down so well – and watch this space for the next ones!

  3. Di says:

    I like the cerise boiled wool coatigan–not that I could wear it, as any animal fibres anywhere near my skin drive me crazy. That colour is good on you Alice.
    Good idea to make up sewing kits and,as Marion George comments, keep it simple. You’ve shown two different looks which is all to do with the fabric choice/colour.
    I made up Vogue 8696 (may be out of print by now) in a crimson ponte. It’s a useful layer for cooler weather, especially with a long sleeved T. Another pattern I’ve used a few times is 1032 by Onion (Danish–there is an English translation). It’s a bit more fitted with a wide shawl collar, raglan sleeves and decorative darts in the back. This too could be out of print or the firm named something that isn’t vegetable related.
    Knitting–no not really my thing. My mothers attempt to knit me a black cardigan for school eventually became —a few years later when I’d left— a cardigan which fitted my father (not a small man). There was a family celebration when it was finally finished. It quickly ended up as a layer he wore when gardening. It also continued to shrink/pill when washed.
    I’ve crocheted jumpers/cardigans –the 70’s ethnic look. Wouldn’t do it now.

    • aliceclothspot says:

      Hello Di – as elsewhere please accept my apologies for a late reply. Your resourcefulness and wealth of experience never fail to dazzle me – I had never heard of Onion patterns but they do indeed exist – although your coatigan jacket does seem to be out of print. But thank you for yet another pattern company to add to my ‘Check here for next project’ list You’re right – I think Vogue 8696 is also out of print but it looks familiar – I’m sure I’ve seen it.
      But knitting – what is it with mothers and over-large cardigans? At least it found a wearer in your father. A chap can never have too many odd pieces of knitwear or fleecewear, it seems…

  4. Marion George says:

    Just a thought for future kits. How about some lovely wide legged trousers in some of that great triple crepe you have? Good luck.

    • aliceclothspot says:

      Thank you for the thought, Marion! That’s a great trouser idea as a looser trouser might not be as tricky to fit – we could pick a pattern that might be more easily fitted than most. In the meantime I thought these might appeal to your sense of humour – just in at John Lewis apparently…. Not sure I’d want to get caught in the rain with them – the chafing!

      • Marion George says:

        Um! Just as wel they are a rarity. Lol. Received the kit. I’m so excited I can’t wait to start it. Weather forecast is for rain today so might be a good time to start.

        • aliceclothspot says:

          My thoughts precisely! I was taught to keep my mouth shut if I couldn’t say anything nice…but I think that might be the exception. Happy sewing! (And please don’t send that rain north – we’re enjoying our sunshine just now…)

    • aliceclothspot says:

      Your comment set us a-pondering, Marion! Trousers aren’t are our next kit but they are definitely on the list. We’ve been having lots of discussions about fitting, and style choices for different body types etc. The nice thing about the triple crepe for trousers (thank you for the nudge) is that the fabric weave means there’s a little bit of forgiving ease built in…

  5. Sharon says:

    What a fabulous idea. I made the grey version and love it. I would never in a million years have picked that pattern and paired it with this fabric, but it worked brilliantly (the fabric is lovely by the way). Would love to see more kits!

    • aliceclothspot says:

      Hello Sharon – thank you very much indeed for the feedback 🙂 I’m delighted to hear that your coatigan went well! I’m actually wearing my grey one right now and when I nip out I will confess to doing a little coatigan-layering and just putting my pink one over the top!

      It’s really encouraging to hear that the pattern and fabric selection that we did for our kits is helpful. It’s something I think we all enjoy, just as we do the process of sewing – but I know from experience it’s also a stage in the process that can be the downfall of a project – so we thought it might be helpful to take some of the uncertainty out of it. I can’t tell you how pleasing it is to know that we got it right – watch this space for more kits, then!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *